The only difference is that Mira wants to maintain her culture and go back to it someday. Some states and localities provide in-state college tuition for undocumented immigrants, some provide driver's licenses, and some are declaring themselves to be sanctuary cities. However, integration does not always improve well-being. However, she also felt what it is like to be an alien in a foreign land while in Canada, and this has a lot of similarities with what Mira is currently undergoing in the U. S. While in Canada, Bharita felt a sense of betrayal by the casual racists outburst elicited by the Green Paper. Residential Integration. As a result, American culture is promoted while the culture of immigrants is destroyed in the lives of the immigrants. Mira still lives in Detroit, works in the Southfield, Mich., school. Bharati Mukherjee's essay, "Two Ways to Belong in America" talks about the experiences of two Indian sisters who migrated to the United States in the early 1960s to further their education and how they have been influenced by the American culture after more than 3 decades. While three-quarters of all immigrants are Christian, immigration is also bringing new religious diversity to the United States. Almost identical in appearance and attitude. Bharati and Mira have been exposed to the same kind of environment and situation, yet they react differently to their immigrant experiences. Two ways to belong in america summary of safety and effectiveness. She along with her husband lived in Canada and placed in a good job. Conquest society in the central mainland areas. Mira was upset about the implementation of the new immigration policy forced upon the old settlers.
Four percent of the foreign-born are Muslim, and although Muslim immigrants are doing better than the national average in education and income, they do report encountering high levels of prejudice and discrimination. She is willing to undergo the trauma of self-transformation in order to become a part of the settled land. For example, immigrants on average come to the United States with better health than native-born Americans, but as they integrate in other ways, they also become less healthy. And here, she surprised me. As a result, the indigenous peoples, once in contact, were very vulnerable to the outsiders. The tone of the essay is reflective and sympathetic while the style adopted is an anecdote (personal). Two ways to belong to america. In the story "two ways to belong to America" the author and narrator Bharati addressed an issue of images of immigrants in America, and what it truly means to belong to a country. This shows that the American culture and Indian culture have remained the same, but Bharati and Mira have changed.
It would have been more convincing for the readers to understand Mira's objection if the author had written extensively on the social and political backgrounds at the time. Like their foreign-born fathers, second generation men were overrepresented in service jobs, although they have largely left agricultural work. Maybe, according to the flow of the story, you intended to write this essay. News & World Report 122. The two different ways to belong as a non-native of this country are, according to Mukherjee, choosing to assimilate or not—immigrants must choose between becoming a part of the culture and country or retaining one's homeland. Two Ways to Belong in America - By Bharati Mukherjee. Unvarying daily core.
Include important data but omit minor points; 2. Among men ages 18-39, the foreign-born are incarcerated at a rate that is one-fourth the rate for the native-born. The indigenous world and the word "Indian". I think the strengths and weakness are mixed up in your writing. You've already summarized this article in the second paragraph.
That does not automatically put them on the path to LPR or citizenship. Easily discuss the questions with your classes when you utilize the extensive answer keys. Everybody experiences it differently, and accordingly, they react as well. Across all measurable outcomes, integration increases over time, with immigrants becoming more like the native-born with more time in the country, and with the second and third generations becoming more like other native-born Americans than their parents were. Still, the well-being of immigrants and their descendants is highly dependent on immigrant starting points and on the segment of American society—the racial and ethnic groups, the legal status, the social class, and the geographic area—into which they integrate. Although the Immigration Act of 1965 exemplified the progressive ideals of the 1960s, the system it engendered may also hinder some immigrants' and their descendants' prospects for integration. And creative, socially courteous and gracious, and that's as far as. Two ways to belong in america summary page. Manipulated and discarded. One difference from earlier waves of immigration is the large percentage of highly skilled immigrants now coming to the United States. Therefore, through her experience in Canada she understands the betrayal her sister feels; that is why she has already acquired American Citizenship. Mukherjee states that if someone is reluctant to assimilate themselves into the new structure, they are exiled from the new country. For Discussion and Writing. This is a tale of two sisters from Calcutta, Mira and Bharati, who. Black immigration has also grown.
I, for the narrowness of her perspective, her uninvolvement with the mythic depths or the superficial pop culture of this society. Mira married an Indian and she is planning to go back to her country and practice her culture someday. Green card of hassle-free residence and employment. Since the mid-1990s, U. immigration policy has become more punitive toward the undocumented, and interior enforcement policies have attempted to prevent their employment and long-term residence in this country. Mira lives there happily as an expatriate Indian with a hope of returning to India after she gets retired rather than living there as an immigrant American whereas Bharati adopts the new American culture and is ready to encounter the trauma of self-transformation in order to become the part of the settled land. The panel's analysis indicates that immigrant family-formation patterns change over time. But, now, with the scapegoatings of "aliens". They pitied one another. SOLUTION: LU Two Ways to belong in America by Bharati Mukherjee Indian Origin Essay - Studypool. In the future, the lines between what Americans today think of as separate. Pairings: This lesson would pair well with a unit on The Joy Luck Club, The Grapes of Wrath, Of Mice and Men, A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, or any other novel or play that deals with the American experience or the immigration experience.
With the looming changes in legal immigration by the US government, many legal immigrants are opting to apply for American citizenship. However stimulated by Mukherjee's ideas, I must be objective while assessing the text. Men from Central America in 2003-2013 were in professional or managerial positions. This distinction Mukherjee draws in the rest of her essay and is, therefore, an appropriate way to phrase it. When you teach your students about the immigration experience with this ready-to-go lesson you will: - Start your classes off with a bellringer freewrite prompt that will help them to focus, get ready to work, and begin to explore the essential questions of the text. United States Immigration. Another way is to fit in with society and to feel as if you belong. S, the two sisters share divergent attitudes and feelings. 2015 marked the 50th anniversary of the passage of the Immigration Act of 1965, which began the most recent period of mass immigration to the United States. Define each of the following words as it is used in this selection. It seems like I have too much to say and there's a lack of transition between the paragraphs, weakening the coherence of my writing.
Despite the positive outlook for linguistic integration, the barriers to English proficiency, particularly for low-skilled, poorly educated, residentially segregated, and undocumented immigrant populations, are cause for concern. She compares the situation in America to the one that she faced in Canada, where the government turned against the immigrants. Interact with the country that we have chosen to live in. Response to the article. I am an American citizen and she is not. Of Canadian parentage. Without all this work, I would be intimidated by the article and unable to assess it. Second generation children of immigrants from Mexico and Central America have made large leaps in occupational terms: 22 percent of second generation Mexican men and 31 percent of second generation. Now a naturalized U. S. citizen, she teaches at the University of California at Berkeley. Although both sisters have different opinions now, they still maintained polite conversation. Wealth and welfare states: Is America a laggard or leader? And another problem is summary, I think. Born children of immigrants, the. Mira on the other hand, being more of an introvert and a patriot of her county/culture felt it necessary to never involved in American culture and felt contentment with her labor certification.
This rule was intentionally made to make immigrants to become citizens of their countries. They are also considered better off, because more education improves their well-being.